Hiring a security consultant can feel like a leap of faith, especially if you’re not a security expert yourself. How do you evaluate someone’s expertise in a field you’re hiring them because you don’t fully understand?
Here’s straightforward guidance on what to look for, what to watch out for, and how to make sure you’re getting real value from the engagement.
Start with What You Actually Need
Before you start evaluating consultants, get clear on what you’re trying to accomplish. The security consulting world is broad, and different firms specialize in different things.
Common needs for small and medium businesses:
- Security assessment: “We want to know where we stand and what to fix”
- Penetration testing: “We want to know if someone could actually break in”
- Compliance alignment: “We need to meet regulatory or contractual requirements”
- Security program development: “We need to build security practices from scratch”
- Incident response: “Something happened and we need help”
- Specific technical review: firewall rules, cloud configuration, Active Directory, etc.
A consultant who’s great at one of these isn’t necessarily great at all of them. Knowing what you need helps you find the right fit.
What to Look For
Relevant Experience
Security is a broad field. Ask about experience that’s relevant to your specific situation:
- Have they worked with businesses your size?
- Do they have experience with your type of environment (on-prem, cloud, hybrid)?
- Have they done the specific type of work you need?
- Can they speak to your industry’s challenges?
A consultant who’s spent 15 years securing Fortune 500 companies has valuable experience, but they might not be the best fit for a 30-person business with a modest IT budget. Look for someone who understands the constraints and realities of your environment.
Clear Communication
Security is full of jargon, and some consultants hide behind it, either intentionally or because they’re so deep in the field they’ve lost the ability to explain things plainly.
A good consultant should be able to:
- Explain what they’re going to do in terms you understand
- Describe findings without drowning you in technical details
- Connect security issues to business impact
- Answer your questions without making you feel uninformed
If someone can’t explain their approach clearly before the engagement, their report probably won’t be clear either.
Defined Deliverables
Before any work begins, you should know exactly what you’re getting. A professional engagement includes:
- Scope document: what’s being tested, reviewed, or assessed
- Timeline: when work starts, how long it takes, when you get results
- Deliverables: what the final output looks like (report format, executive summary, remediation guidance)
- Pricing: transparent, tied to the scope, with no hidden fees
Be cautious of consultants who are vague about deliverables. “We’ll assess your security and provide recommendations” isn’t specific enough. What systems? What methodology? What format? These details matter.
Credentials (But Keep Perspective)
Certifications matter, but they’re not everything. Here’s a balanced take:
Certifications that demonstrate broad security knowledge:
- CISSP: widely recognized, covers a broad range of security domains
- CISM: focused on security management and governance
- CompTIA Security+: solid foundation-level certification
Certifications that demonstrate technical depth:
- OSCP/OSCE: hands-on offensive security (penetration testing)
- GIAC certifications: specialized technical areas (forensics, incident response, cloud security)
Certifications tell you someone studied and passed an exam. They don’t tell you whether they can communicate clearly, manage a project, or deliver useful results. Look at certifications as part of the picture, not the whole picture.
References and Examples
Ask for:
- References from businesses similar to yours
- Sample deliverables: redacted reports or executive summaries that show the quality of their output
- Case studies: how they’ve helped businesses in comparable situations
If a consultant can’t provide any evidence of past work, that’s a red flag.
What to Watch Out For
Fear-Based Selling
“You’re going to get breached if you don’t hire us immediately” is a sales tactic, not professional advice. Security risks are real, but a good consultant educates you; they don’t scare you into buying.
Be wary of anyone who leads with fear and urgency rather than understanding your specific situation first.
Scope Creep Without Communication
Projects sometimes uncover more than expected, and that’s normal. But a consultant who keeps expanding the engagement without discussing it with you first is a problem.
The right approach: “During our assessment we found X, which is outside the original scope. Here’s what it means and what it would cost to include. Your call.”
Jargon Without Substance
Some consultants deliver reports full of technical findings with no business context. A 50-page vulnerability report with no prioritization, no executive summary, and no remediation guidance isn’t useful; it’s overwhelming.
Your report should tell you: what’s most important, what it means for your business, and what to do about it in what order.
One-Size-Fits-All Approaches
Your business is different from every other business. A consultant who offers the same package to everyone, regardless of environment, isn’t tailoring their work to your actual needs.
Look for someone who asks questions about your environment, your goals, and your constraints before proposing a solution.
Long-Term Contracts Upfront
Be cautious of consultants who push ongoing retainers or multi-year contracts before they’ve done any work for you. Project-based engagements let you evaluate the relationship and the quality of work before making a bigger commitment.
Questions to Ask Before You Hire
Here’s a practical checklist for your evaluation conversations:
- What’s your experience with businesses like ours? (Size, industry, environment type)
- What methodology do you use? (They should be able to explain their approach clearly)
- What does the deliverable look like? (Ask for a sample or description)
- How do you handle findings outside the original scope? (Tests their communication approach)
- What certifications and experience does your team have? (Verify credentials)
- Can you provide references? (From businesses similar to yours)
- What’s included in the price? (Scope, deliverables, follow-up)
- What’s your availability and timeline? (Realistic scheduling)
The Bottom Line
Hiring a security consultant is an investment in understanding and improving your security posture. The right consultant gives you clarity, actionable guidance, and confidence that you’re spending your limited resources where they matter most.
The wrong one gives you a pile of jargon, a vague sense of anxiety, and a lighter wallet.
Take the time to evaluate. Ask the hard questions. And look for someone who treats the engagement as a partnership, where the goal is to educate and empower your team, not create dependency.
At DC Security Solutions, this is how we approach every engagement: clear scope, transparent pricing, actionable results, and a focus on helping you understand your security, not just checking a box.
– Derek, Founder of DC Security Solutions.
DC Security Solutions offers custom security engagements tailored to your business needs. Learn more →